• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Features
  • Campus News
  • CSUDH.edu
  • Contact
  • People
    • Staff Spotlight
    • Faculty Highlights
    • Alumni
  • Magazine
  • For Journalists
    • CSUDH In The News
    • Press Releases
    • Facts and Figures
    • Find Media Experts
    • Gallery
    • News Reporting on Campus

CSUDH News

The primary source of news and information about California State University, Dominguez Hills, its students, faculty, and staff.

You are here: Home / Archive / Features / Ana Pitchon: Working Toward a Sea Change in Fishing Industry, Conservationism

Ana Pitchon: Working Toward a Sea Change in Fishing Industry, Conservationism

February 2, 2011

Ana Pitchon (center) presented research on the designation of Marine Protected Areas with psychology student John Bunce at the CSU Office of the Chancellor. Pictured with CSU Dominguez Hills President Mildred García
Dr. Ana Pitchon (center) made a presentation on Marine Protected Areas with psychology student John Bunce at the CSU Office of the Chancellor. Pictured with CSU Dominguez Hills President Mildred García

Ana Pitchon, assistant professor of anthropology, presented a poster on the practice of forming stakeholder groups when designating Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) during a session on the California State University’s Council on Ocean Affairs, Science and Technology (COAST) at the CSU Office of the Chancellor in Long Beach. Presentations from 20 of the CSU’s 23 campuses were shown during an annual meeting of CSU presidents on Jan. 25.  Pitchon created “Competing ideologies, policy, and marine protected areas” with psychology major John Bunce. Their collaboration was the only student-mentor team that applied the social sciences to the study of the ocean at the event.

Pitchon says that MPAs are constructed and implemented by a variety of interests, including state and federal regulatory agencies, conservationists, fishermen, and academics. She says that while each group brings valuable information to the table, the system is flawed due to the cultural dynamics of each subgroup of stakeholders.

“Given John’s interest in psychology, we’ve been talking about some of the more psychological and personal aspects of the MPA process,” says Pitchon. “In California right now, we’re going through an implementation process of [designating] marine protected areas along the entire state. Task forces are established among stakeholders in order to figure out where [MPAs] should be that would not be too disruptive for any one group.”

Pitchon says that she and Bunce used social identity theory to draw their conclusion that despite the strong social and professional identities of the individual groups of stakeholders, the members of these groups have to be able to transcend their own beliefs in order to achieve common ground.

“When people are put into groups, they immediately adhere to the standards of that group and form solidarity around the [collective] characteristics or ideology,” says Pitchon. “Our conclusion is for a process like this to be more streamlined and functional, there has to be an underlying thread that can somehow break people [free] of their group ideology and form more cohesive units that are able to work together and transcend ideologically contrived boundaries.”

Bunce, who minors in anthropology, says that their study is part of California’s first wave of examining the MPA designation process and is hopeful that their findings will help guide decision making in the future.

“The strength of MPA development seems to be this stakeholder idea, that also seems to be a potential weakness with the intergroup conflict that it seems to foster,” says Bunce. “The stakeholder group offers a great deal of information to people at the top, but ultimately breaks down the ability of those stakeholders to come back and form consensus. Their social identities create a conflict. There may be a need to allow the stakeholder groups to go into a fact-finding stage then find some way to… bring the groups back together outside of it. The key is to find some way to create intergroup dialogue that breaks down those boundaries.”

Pitchon has had extensive experience in studying the effects of man-made solutions to depletion of native species due to overfishing. She will be speaking on “Sea Hunters or Sea Farmers? Transitions in Modern Fisheries” at the Aquarium of the Pacific in Long Beach on Feb. 23. Her talk is based on her research of a coastal community in Chiloé Island, Chile, that had lost its centuries-old artisanal fishing industry. Pitchon found that the introduction of salmon farms to the region resulted in adverse effects upon the community.

“Wild capture fisheries are in decline and artisanal small-scale fishermen are losing their ability to make a living off of this craft,” she says. “Their grandfathers did it, their great-grandfathers did it. More than just making a living, it was a way of life. Near-shore species are disappearing due to overfishing, pollution from the salmon farms, and the price of farmed species.”

While visiting Chiloé from 2005 to 2006, Pitchon looked at the community’s transition from wild capture fisheries to salmon farming. Using methods that were unprecedented in this type of research, she measured indicators such as quality of life and/or perceived well-being, job satisfaction, and environmental values in order to determine the island’s resiliency to the changes. She says that while the global phenomenon of aquaculture is often seen by governments as a way to rescue failing wild-capture fisheries, her study proved that the stability of both this coastal population and its ecosystem were at risk.

“The social networks started to disintegrate,” Pitchon notes. “People became much more dependent on external institutions for wage labor, whereas before, people had a tradition of reciprocity because life on the island is so difficult. Before the farms were there, people would trade seafood for firewood. Their quality of life and perceived well-being plummeted because they weren’t using any of their skills. They were working with fish, but they didn’t have any connection to [salmon] because it’s non-native to this environment.”

Along with the cultural losses of Chiloé’s fishing community, the conditions of aquaculture and the introduction of salmon, a non-native species, wreaked their ecological effects on the community.

“We talk about invasive species like kudzu in the South and the zebra mussel in the Great Lakes,” Pitchon says. “We know now that introducing a species to solve an ecological problem is typically a bad idea. A new species will often adapt and colonize which will create changes.”

Pitchon cites influences from the food web to diseases that are unique to farmed salmon as responsible for long-term damage to Chiloé’s ecosystem – and to consumers of the fish being raised. She says that the escape of the carnivorous salmon from their pens, whether orchestrated by curious sea lions or the fish themselves, resulted in new salmon colonies that competed with native species for resources. In addition, the use of antibiotics to treat diseases resulted in the build-up of chemicals in the ocean and the loss of a food source for humans.

“The pens are in environments where they say the current is going to take care of chemicals and wash them away, but the truth is that a significant amount of food, antibiotics, and detritus falls to the sea floor,” Pitchon says. “Sometimes it creates hypoxic zones underneath the salmon pens. Contamination from the pens and from salmon processing plants that wash out their waste enters the near-shore environment where families are dependent on the fish that thrive in these areas. These fish are starting to disappear because of all the contamination.”

Pitchon’s research in Chiloé which has just been accepted for publication in Human Organization, the journal of the Society for Applied Anthropology.  She has begun work on a similar project analyzing concepts of resilience and near-shore coastal resource use in Puerto Rico, funded by a Sea Grant from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). She will be examining the ways that near-shore resources can be used in times of economic stress as a subsistence bailout.

Pitchon has also recently received a grant to work with the Santa Monica Bay Restoration Commission on “Bridging the Market Gap: Educating Fishermen and the Public for Sustainable Seafood and Communities.” The project addresses the concern in Southern California of sustainable seafood production,  and aims to educate the extended fishing community through an outreach initiative that works to enhance local seafood products for use in local markets, which will also have an impact on catch reduction and increased economic value for community sustainability.

In 2004, Pitchon was awarded a Fulbright Comprehensive Mutual Educational and Cultural Exchange Scholarship for her dissertation research in Chiloé, Chile. She is a member of the Board of Governors for the Ocean Studies Institute of Southern California, the CSU Dominguez Hills representative to the CSU’s COAST, a member of the Marine Resources Advisory Team for the Santa Monica Bay Restoration Commission, and a member of the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission of UNESCO. She is a founding member of the Society for Anthropological Sciences, and an active member of the Society for Applied Anthropology, the International Association for the Study of the Commons, and the Society for Advancement of Chicanos and Native Americans in Science.

Pitchon says that as evidenced in her research throughout the United States and South America, when looking at natural food sources such as seafood, “It is all connected. Being an anthropologist, my particular interest is in the people and the communities and their dependence on these resources and how can they stay afloat.”

For more information on anthropology at CSU Dominguez Hills, click here.

 

 

 

 

Filed Under: Features Tagged With: Anthropology, Faculty, Research, Students

Recent Features

Ricardo Martinez with fellow youth commissioners at an outreach event in 2022.

Toro Makes an Impact as Youth Commissioner

January 12, 2023

At 23, CSUDH junior Ricardo Ortega Martinez Jr. is already a veteran in California politics. “My advocacy and community organizing started at the age of 17,” says Martinez, a political science major whose early experience with foster care growing up in Huntington Park helped shape the focus of his current advocacy ... Read More

Ken Seligson with The Maya and Climate Change book in foreground

New Book Explores the Resilience of the Ancient Maya

December 2, 2022

Throughout human history, civilizations have had to adapt to ever-shifting environments in order to survive—whether sudden, catastrophic climate events, or gradual changes that span centuries. These human-environmental relationships are at the center of The Maya and Climate Change (Oxford University Press, Nov. 2022), ... Read More

Helping Student Vets Chart a Path to Success

November 10, 2022

Tucked away on the third floor of Leo F. Cain Library, the Veterans Resource Center (VRC) may be small, but it exerts an outsized influence on the lives of students making the challenging transition from military service to academic life. “The Veterans Resource Center is the reason I’m here today and about to ... Read More

... see all Featured Stories

Primary Sidebar

Social Media

Facebook
Twitter
Youtube
Instagram
LinkedIn
SOCIALICON

Secondary Sidebar

CSUDH EXPERTS

Student Research Day Showcases Scholarship and Mentorship

Now in its 13th year, Student Research Day (SRD) has become an institution at California State University, Dominguez Hills (CSUDH), and a widely-anticipated showcase of the analytical and creative vigor demonstrated each year by the university’s budding researchers. Close to 220 oral and poster presentations were delivered during SRD on Feb. 14 and 15, covering a wide range of academic ... Read More

[VIDEO] Teatro Dominguez: The Best Kept Secret at CSUDH

It might be uncommon to see second and third grade students volunteer to pick up trash, but that is exactly what has happened during California State University, Dominguez Hills' (CSUDH) Teatro Dominguez community-based theater troupe performances at local elementary schools this semester. When the college student actors— in character as a coyote, an aardvark, a sea cucumber and other sea, land ... Read More

Zero Waste Goals Require Toro Nation to be All-In

As the Earth’s dominant species, humans have a myriad of self-inflicted ecological challenges to contend with. Some are monumental and require international buy-in, like climate change, while others involve localized activism and direct action, such as biohazard cleanup. One cause of all the devastation stands out above the rest – waste. CSUDH has a large ecological footprint. The campus ... Read More

photo of phone with low battery

Your Phone Is Almost Out of Battery. Remain Calm. Call A Doctor.

Larry Rosen knows he has a problem. Headed home from work, the psychology professor said his heart skipped a beat when he glanced at his iPhone and suddenly realized his battery was at 7%. He had no charger. “You get this feeling: Oh my God, I’m lost,” he said. Prof. Rosen, a past chairman of the psychology department at California State University, Dominguez Hills, knows whereof he speaks. He ... Read More

Young Scholars Program Marks 20 Years of Educating High School Students

Thousands of high school students throughout California have been able to earn college credit prior to graduation—saving them money and reducing their time to a college degree— through the California State University, Dominguez Hills Young Scholars Program, which turns 20 in 2014. To mark the anniversary and showcase the program, Center for Mediated Instruction and Distance Learning staff ... Read More

Ximena Cid

Ximena Cid Stands on ‘Path of Totality’ After Teaching STEM 0 Students about Total Solar Eclipses

On Aug. 21, Ximena Cid was standing with family and friends in Idaho on the “path of totality,” watching the bright morning sky dim to a twilight hue and feeling the air temperature steadily drop while the moon gradually blocked the sun’s light from reaching Earth. Cid, an assistant professor of physics at California State University, Dominguez Hills (CSUDH), was far from alone during her ... Read More

Women’s Studies Grants First Degrees

Women’s Studies Grants First Degrees

Women’s Studies has only been a major at CSUDH for one year, but its first four graduates are already earning their degrees this spring. As Associate Professor and Coordinator of Women’s Studies Jenn Brandt says, “We’re so excited. To have all of these wonderful students, in a pandemic, not only surviving but thriving, has exceeded my expectations! I know they’re going to go on and make the ... Read More

Women’s Business Conference Inspires, Informs and Connects Entrepreneurs

Nearly 2,000 women (and several men) who either are small business owners or are considering becoming one filled the Loker Student Union at California State University, Dominguez Hills for the 2014 Connecting Women to Power Business Conference on June 20. The capacity crowd was on hand to gain invaluable tips on a variety of topics facing small business owners, including how to build a ... Read More

Women’s Business Conference Enlightens and Empowers

Approximately 1,000 women (and a few brave men) from throughout much of Southern California—who already are or are interested in becoming small business owners—gathered at the 2012 Connecting Women to Power Business Conference held at California State University, Dominguez Hills on June 14. The large crowd was treated to rousing keynote and welcome speeches laced together by master of ceremonies ... Read More

Women’s Conference: Students as Architects of Their Own Lives

By:Wyahee Tucrkile How do I build the life I want to build? How do I create the space around me to make that structure strong enough to withstand the things that it might need to withstand? As students and faculty from California State University, Dominguez Hills and local high schools including Fremont, Firebaugh, Crenshaw, and Lynwood High School, sat in a nearly packed Loker Student Union ... Read More

Women’s Business Conference Brings Policymakers and Entrepreneurs Together

The National Association of Women Business Owners – LA (NAWBOLA) and California Educational Solutions, in partnership with members of the California State Board of Equalization, hosted the “Connecting Women to Power Business Conference” in the Loker Student Union at California State University, Dominguez Hills on March 30. The State Board of Equalization was represented by Jerome Horton (Class of ... Read More

Footer

California State University, Dominguez Hills Logo

1000 E. Victoria Street, Carson, CA 90747
1-310-243-2001 • Send Email

Related Sites

  • csudh.edu
  • magazine.csudh.edu
  • gotoros.com

EMAIL NEWSLETTER

Get CSUDH News directly in your inbox

Copyright © 2023 · California State University, Dominguez Hills